Once upon a time, on a Friday afternoon, a girl was sitting at her computer. What she didn’t know then, as she ate her Fourth of July leftovers for lunch, is that within the next two hours, she would have ordered two new sofas. Spoiler alert- said “girl” was actually me and this is a true story. And, she now has a full Pottery Barn sofa comparison.
*Posts on KelleyNan.com may contain affiliate links. Click HERE for full disclosure.*
Let’s back up a little… If you are a regular reader, you probably know of our big sectional in the great room. You also probably know about my love/hate relationship with it. I love the functionality, I love the comfort and it has so much room. But, I ordered it before we moved in and it takes up so much space (a little too much space for us). It’s also a little darker than I would prefer against our greige walls. And, 3/4 of the sofa remains untouched because it’s just me and Dave. The worst part which I hadn’t considered is (in case you didn’t know, both Dave and I are on the shorter side) because of our height, we have a difficult time getting in and out of it- especially the chaise. And with the shape of our room, the chaise has been more of a hindrance. When we broke the coffee table over NYE during a lively game of jumbo Jenga, I didn’t want to pay to replace it, knowing I had my eyes on eventually replacing our sofa for something that fit our space (and needs) a little better. So, here it sits, seven months later, with an oversized tray holding down the broken mirrored glass. Real safe, right? haha
I’ve been looking at sofas casually for months. I had looked at a few from Crate and Barrel and had even considered the Axis II. But, knowing I didn’t want to commit to something for many years down the road, I wanted to find a happy medium – something nice that wouldn’t break the bank and that I wouldn’t cry about spending the money on. I also knew I would be spending more on high performance fabric so the cost would likely be a good bit higher than the base price of the sofa. Our current sofa wasn’t cheap and the decision to divorce it wasn’t an easy one.
POTTERY BARN SOFA COMPARISON
Pottery Barn has pretty frequent sales and my mind was pushing me in that direction; we’ve been really happy with all the upholstered furniture we’ve ever purchased there (see our Thatcher Wingback Chairs – shown in the photo above – and former Tall Tufted Lorraine Bed– also purchased together during a Buy More, Save More event). But, when I saw their occasional – Buy More, Save More event (up to 30% off when you spend $3,000+) – I decided it was time to go and test some out, in store. The three I was considering were the Pearce, the Cameron, and the Buchanan. I had heard great things about the PB Comfort but it was just too deep for us (more on that in a bit). A few things to keep in mind:
- Each sofa is made to order, so you select your own fabric. We decided before we even headed out that especially because we love on our sofas hard (and because we wanted to go with a light fabric), we would need to get a higher (more expensive) performance fabric.
- Each sofa comes in a slip-covered option. I knew I wanted upholstered so I don’t include the slip-covered options in the comparison.
- Each sofa comes in a standard size, grand size, love seat size, and sectional. The sectionals are not included in the comparison below. I knew I wanted a sofa and love seat going into it so that is what our focus was on.
- Each sofa comes in a roll arm and square arm option. We decided on the square arm pretty quickly. Surprising, the square arm is still padded and comfortable.
- The roll arm sofas are longer but that is due to the arm size; the seat size is the same.
Here’s a run-down of our trip.
POTTERY BARN CAMERON SOFA
What We Liked:
- Aesthetic
- Price
- The grand is available in the longest length
What We Didn’t Like:
- The depth – this was the most narrow of the sofas and I actually kind of liked the depth. My feet don’t usually touch the ground while sitting on sofas and they did on the Cameron. Dave was ok with it too but thought something a little wider would be more conducive for naps. The back cushions are removable, which would have been fine, too.
- It doesn’t come with the down wrapped cushion option
*all images via PotteryBarn.com
POTTERY BARN PEARCE SOFA
What We Liked:
- Aesthetic
- Comes with down wrapped cushions
- Low feet
What We Didn’t Like:
- The depth – this depth was actually pretty good but I would have preferred just an inch or two more shallow.
- Two seat cushions- I actually like the look and think it would be great for lying on but when I started imagining the rare occasion of having someone sit in the middle, I didn’t like the idea of them having to share the two cushions.
- The lengths are on the shorter side – the “grand” size is actually almost the same size as the love seat size in other models. Ultimately, this was the deciding factor on why we decided against it.
POTTERY BARN BUCHANAN SOFA
What We Liked:
- Aesthetic
- Price
- Perfect depth
What We Didn’t Like:
- It doesn’t come with the down wrapped cushion option. This was the biggest contention when I was deciding whether or not to pull the trigger.
- The love seat is pretty large- That isn’t a bad thing but it does make me nervous – I’m hoping I measured correctly!
Here’s a quick breakdown of the factors we considered in comparing each of the Pottery Barn sofas – I wish I had created this prior to our trip!
THE WINNER…
Ultimately, we went… with the Buchanan Square Arm Sofas! We ordered one grand and one love seat in Ivory Crypton performance fabric. A huge thank you to Tricia at the Alpharetta Avalon location who was a total gem, super informative, and beyond patient.
We were able to see a large piece of fabric in-store and they even had another sofa upholstered in it. I didn’t want something too cool or too yellow or too white – basically the perfect light neutral. I asked Dave if he knew when we took our little impromptu field trip we would be coming home with new sofas on the way – he gave me that look like “you can’t be serious” but I told him, “that’s funny because I didn’t even know!” It’s true- he knows me and my ways better than I know myself. Because we were able to get 30% off, we saved about $1,000 and I was shocked at how reasonable the final price was – even after the upgraded fabric, tax, and white glove delivery. If you have never ordered a large PB piece, when they deliver, they set everything up for you, where you want it. This even goes for beds.
I’ll be sure to report back and I’ll definitely be sharing them once they arrive (an estimated 6-8 weeks) and of course the other changes I’ll be making as a result (that shattered coffee table can’t make its exit fast enough!). If you are in the market for a new sofa(s), this will help as a guide for some of the specifics we were looking for but do your own research when it comes to sustainability and preferences. Our situation was finding something with good quality that would last – but not the best quality that would be a huge investment for decades. If these do, I would be thrilled! I know that years down the road, if you do think your cushions aren’t as plump as they used to be, you can order replacements.
Scroll & Tap to Shop the Post
Make sure to subscribe to my emails at the bottom of this post, and don’t miss when our Buchanan sofas arrive! Plus, I’ll be sharing other updates and living room projects soon.
Other Posts You May be Interested In
- How to Mix & Match Bedroom Furniture Finishes
- Updated Foyer Lighting: Before and After Darlana Pendant
- Form vs. Function in the Family Room: Balancing the Pretty vs. the Practical
- Favorite White Budget Friendly Curtains
Marion Duffield says
July 8, 2018 at 9:17 pmCongratulations on your purchase! I cracked up at Dave’s look ‘you can’t be serious ‘ lololol I cannot wait to see it in its new space. I am sure you are going to have that room looking even more beautiful than it does now!
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:35 amMarion, I’ve come to know that look all too well! haha!
Kelly says
July 8, 2018 at 9:19 pmI loved reading your sofa comparisons and it is very timely as I am starting to look for a new sofa! I’ve put it off for a long time because it is such a daunting task! We have had our Bernhardt sofa and chair for a long time…too long even though it has held up well and still looks good but I’m ready for an update! I want light and bright and not too expensive, all the things you described! I love that you have been so detailed with your descriptions and it helps me immensely! Your home is beautiful and as I said before – you are the most helpful and consistent blogger that I follow and I really do thank you for all you do!
Hugs,
Kelly from TX:)
Kelley Nan says
July 8, 2018 at 9:29 pmKelly, oh my goodness, that truly is the ultimate compliment. THANK YOU! And I get it- even if you can pay top dollar for a sofa that will last 50 years, do you really want to? Haha. I will keep you posted and am anxious for them to arrive!
Gretchen Thomas says
July 8, 2018 at 10:06 pmI am so excited for you, as I know this is a major and long time purchase. Loved the look and comfort of your sectional. But…reflecting back, you have always had to give me a push to get up from it! ???? Can’ wait to see your new look!
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:35 amHAHAH! That is so true! It’s the pre-bedtime workout 😉
Bridget says
July 8, 2018 at 10:19 pmI was just at PB last week sofa testing. The Buchanan was also my favorite. I’ve been trying to decide if I want slipcovered or upholstery…I have my eye on the Performance Heather Tweed in Ivory. Nice to know that you like it too after a very thorough comparison!
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:36 amBridget, how coincidental! Just hearing that makes me more confident in our choice!!
Kim says
July 9, 2018 at 2:08 pmIf you have kids, then I would definitely suggest the slipped covered option. We have the PB Comfort slipped covered couch (granite it’s pretty light in color) we have 2 small kids and this thing launders VERY well. We wash it a lot! WE have just recently renovated our basement and will be needing a couch down there and I am not going to hesitate to go with another PB couch!
Kelley Nan says
July 10, 2018 at 12:48 pmI know several people who have the slip covered with no regrets, too- so glad you have been so pleased with yours!
Jennifer says
July 8, 2018 at 10:25 pmSo excited for you Kelley! I’m impressed with how thorough you were too! Can’t wait to see the rest of the changes and the new sofas when they arrive! xo
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:37 amJen, I’m feeling like you now! Literally, all over the place- a little here, a little there. Except, you’ve been able to beautifully finish spaces; I’m still turning in circles! haha
Tricia Crawford says
July 8, 2018 at 10:28 pmExcellent comparisons and very helpful for those in the market for new sofas. With so many options, it is a lot to think about! Thank you for stopping by our store and giving me the opportunity to assist you- such a pleasure!
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:33 amTricia, thank YOU for being so helpful; it was a pleasure meeting you and I look forward to visiting again!
Sharna says
July 8, 2018 at 10:33 pmGreat post. Thank you for the timely and useful information!
By the way,
Hinderance = Hindrance
Laying = Lying
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:40 amI’m glad it was helpful!
Becky says
July 8, 2018 at 10:49 pmI hope the Krypton fabric holds up for you. When we moved into our home nearly 5 years ago we had our then couches reupholstered in a light iovry/white Krypton fabric from Calico. It was nice for a while, but then the fabric started to pill up like a sweater, in the places we sat often. We shaved it many times, but eventually we couldn’t shave the fabric enough to look good. It also didn’t clean up as well as I thought it should. So we ditched those couches and bought some that have washable slipcovers. I worked hard to find couches that looked decent with the slipcover option and I am still thrilled with our choice two years later. I hope Krypton has improved their wearability so that you can enjoy your new couches for many years. Great choice in couch style and size – I’m sure they will look perfect in your lovely space!
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:29 amHi, Becky! I think tweed-like material (both high quality and otherwise) has a tendency to pill. That was one question I asked about the specific fabric I chose and they assured me that it shouldn’t be a problem with that type of material. I’m definitely excited to get them!
Janet says
July 8, 2018 at 11:55 pmSo very timely as I too have been sofa shopping and am also strongly considering taking the plunge tomorrow night on the last day of the 30% off offerwith Pottery Barn. I looked at a few other options outside of PB but don’t want to spend my hard-earned money and settle on something that I’m not really that thrilled with. I also am looking at the Buchanan and considered the 80″ PB Comfort sofa but agree that the 39 inch depth is ideal for me. I wish their shipping charges weren’t so high but I have several things from PB that I just absolutely love, including a media console. So glad you shared your observations. One downside … with most sofas nowadays having a lower profile my cats will not be able to hide under the sofa when guests come over. I do feel badly about that. ?
Kelley Nan says
July 9, 2018 at 8:27 amHi, Janet! What a coincidence! I agree- for us, the Buchanan seemed like the perfect fit. Also with you in that I don’t want to skimp on such an important, functional piece but also don’t want to trap myself in having to have it for 20 years to get my money’s worth haha. Their shipping isn’t cheap but after seeing how they’ve delivered and set up other pieces, I’m a-ok with it. You’ll have to let me know if you pull the trigger!
Janet Bracey says
July 19, 2018 at 2:02 amI did pull the trigger and ordered the Buchanan loveseat, chair and ottoman. Wondering if I should have considered one or two of their Thatcher wingback chairs in lieu of the armchair because of my small LR set up but too late to change. Am excited about their new performance brushed basketweave cotton fabric–so soft! Liked both the oatmeal and sand colors but settled on oatmeal. Coming first week of September!
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 8:41 amJanet, how exciting!!! I have some items in oatmeal (I think that’s what my wingbacks are) and love the color. I would love to see a photo when you get everything in!
Marissa Smith says
July 9, 2018 at 1:40 pmKelley- great choice!!! I’ve placed the Buchanan in many client’s homes since they came out with this piece about 5 years ago. My clients love it all for the same reasons you list. I’ve never placed an order in your fabric selection, but I’ve seen it in person and it’s beautiful. Can’t wait to see these pieces in your home!
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 9:14 amMarissa, that makes me even more excited. THANK YOU for sharing!!
Susie @ Chelsea Project says
July 10, 2018 at 7:04 pmThanks for this fabulous info. I’m currerntly shopping for sofas and love the PB brand. But I’m like you….a little vertically challenged.. LOL..So the info about the depth was key. Congrats on your purchase. Looking forward to seeing it in place. Wish me luck…..as I’m still so undecided. 🙁 Susie from The Chelsea Project
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 9:16 amSusie, it’s a big decision! I was stagnant, doing online research for months until I finally went in-store. Then, I was just able to make that decision! (finally). Good luck finding the perfect sofa for you and your fam!
Colleen says
July 10, 2018 at 7:05 pmI have two PB Comfort sofas and I HATE them! To be fair, I cheaped out and didn’t get the down cushions and went with a lower end fabric, but they started to fail almost from day one. The seat cushions flattened. The fabric stretched (it’s 100% cotton). The back cushions have a little dog leg that goes over the arm and the stuffing shifted out of it. It’s impossible to get it back in no matter how much I shake and pluck at it. I even opened one up and replaced the (really nasty, nylon-like) filling with fiberfill but it still looks bad.
On the plus side, the frame is very sturdy. The cushion covers come off and can be washed. They looked great in the beginning!
I think if you go with the down cushions and performance fabrics, you will have a better experience that I have. But my next sofa will be a $500 piece from Wayfair!
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 9:17 amColleen, I hate you didn’t like your PB Comfort- they are BIG but the down filled one I tested in store was almost like a bed! I do know you can get replacement cushions from PB- if you are still on the fence, trying to make it work, it may be worth it to give them a call?
Colleen says
July 26, 2018 at 7:21 pmThat’s a great idea Kelley! It never occurred to me. It would be nice to get a few more years out of them. Thank you!!!!
Corine says
July 11, 2018 at 6:20 pmHi, Kelly, we recently purchased the Pearce sofa and ended up getting the recliner to match. Not sure what your issue with the down was, but I would have preferred not to have any down in my cushions, but that wasn’t a choice.
We ordered it in February and received it in May – a long lead time.
I would say it is on the petite size, but I’m small and so is the room, so it works ok.
Like you, I had a fab designer in Scottsdale who had endless patience.
I admit I like my Ethan Allen purchase better, but this was about half the cost.
We haven’t really had it long enough to give it much of a review, but so far so good.
Best to you!
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 9:20 amCorine, that is good to hear! My selection doesn’t come with a down option; sounds like we are opposite on preferences! I know people who purchased EA sofas who have had them for half a lifetime. But, as you said, I didn’t want to commit to a “half a lifetime price tag” on these haha. I hope you end up loving your new pieces!
DeAnn says
July 14, 2018 at 10:34 amThank you for the info. I am also in the hunt. I was interested in the same sofa. Do you know if they have any with white piping? Or any of the sofas? I can’t seem to find one of that style with piping. I really want a soft grey with white piping. Help!
Kelley Nan says
July 23, 2018 at 9:23 amHi, Deann! I don’t believe you can choose your piping to make it a contrasting color on any of the PB sofas.
Sue says
July 24, 2018 at 1:33 amSofa shopping can be daunting! It sounds like you did your research so you should be happy! I hope you like them. Love the fabric color!
I purchased a new sofa as well this year. I did a ton of research and decided on a tight back sofa and love it. I went with a darker neutral with the fabric as well after years of white and light colored sofas. I was pretty nervous about that but I really like it. The tight back always looks so crisp. It’s not a forever sofa, but I find I am ready for a different style every few years or so. (I had a big landscaping project this year so that took priority.) The important thing is that it looks great and it’s a good napping sofa.?
Kelley Nan says
July 27, 2018 at 11:50 amSue, sounds like YOU did YOUR research! That’s awesome and I totally agree. I think that’s awesome you found a good compromise and are pleased but didn’t blow or go beyond your budget!
Amy Scholz says
October 26, 2018 at 7:57 pmHave you received your sofas yet? I am considering the Buchanan sectional. Thanks!
Kelley Nan says
November 1, 2018 at 3:03 pmHi, Amy! YES! So far, so good! You can see our progress update here: https://kelleynan.com/affordable-transitional-living-room-furnishings/
Kelly Welling says
January 21, 2019 at 10:54 amThis post is so helpful. I have been researching sofas for months and I keep coming back to this one. I haven’t been able to see one in person though because they don’t have it on the floor in our store. One thing I’m concerned about is the cushions. I don’t want the down cushions anyway, but I had pretty much decided I wanted memory foam. These just say polyester unlike other PB sofas that have a memory foam option. Would you tell me anything you can about the cushions. I’m concerned about sagging in the long run.
Love your blog.
Kelley Nan says
January 23, 2019 at 5:51 pmHi, Kelly! The Cameron is going to be really similar to the Buchanan and has the same seat (it’s just going to be more shallow than the Buchanan). If they have that in store, that will give you a better idea. We haven’t had any sagging (we also haven’t used them rigorously). I can’t compare to any that have memory foam; I’m so sorry!!
Stephen says
February 20, 2019 at 9:02 amHi Kelly-thanks for the sofa review. I have to ask…your big sectional in the picture, where is that from? That is exactly what I am looking for currently, but can’t find the right fit but this would be perfect!
Kelley Nan says
April 4, 2019 at 11:42 amLazboy!
Terri Hicke says
March 27, 2019 at 4:50 pmHi Kelly,
Weird question- where was your big sectional from that you had before you got the pottery barn couches?
Kelley Nan says
April 4, 2019 at 11:32 amHi, Terri! LaZBoy 😉
Monica Waisner says
April 6, 2019 at 11:38 pmHi Kelly. It is Divine Intervention that I found your post on the PB couches tonight! I’m trying to purchase a couch for my daughter who lives in TX and I’m here in Atlanta which makes it very challenging. I was in PB today looking at the Buchanan and thought it was perfect for her first “real” furniture. I too am a little concerned about not having a down wrapped cushion option and wondered how your cushions are performing. Sales lady said the couch in the store feels like down because so many people sit on it but that when it comes to your home it takes a long time for the cushions to soften up. Can you please weigh in on that? Also, any pilling with this fabric? Thanks so much!
Kelley Nan says
May 15, 2019 at 8:27 amMonica, I’m so sorry I’m just seeing this and you may have already made a decision! So, the performance fabric we chose has NOT pilled at all. The cushions DO take time to break in but for us, still look great. We don’t use them as “hard” as some families yet but they still look great. It is such a great price (during the big sales) but isn’t our forever sofas. If I had to choose, while these have served us well for the price, I will say that I think I would prefer the down.
Ashley Bullock says
August 9, 2019 at 10:37 pmThis was soooo helpful! We’re purchasing a new sofa (sectional) and we’re looking at the Pearce. How has your sofa held up after a year? Also, how on earth did you get 30% off?!
Kelley Nan says
August 13, 2019 at 8:59 amAshley, it has held up very well — especially surprising with the price. They will have buy more, save more sales u to 30% off a few times a year!!
Lindsay says
August 16, 2019 at 9:42 amI have been trying to decide on a fabric and was between the performance tweed and the ivory crypton and this has helped me decide on fabric, but still curious if you’re pleased with that fabric? I think I just read a post that you would have preferred down over the memory foam? That’s what I’m struggling with now. We are going with the PB comfort I think because we do want deep.
Kelley Nan says
August 21, 2019 at 2:40 pmLindsay, I am still 100% pleased with the fabric (and that is with three dirty dogs lounging). Yes, I do wish I had the down (ours didn’t come in that option) but I think the comfort does!